Philip Kingsley: winning the answer, not just the click

The situation icon

The situation

Every brand that built its traffic on helpful content is having the same uncomfortable conversation right now. Someone asks Google why their hair is thinning or how to deal with a flaky scalp and the answer appears at the top of the page in an AI Overview. They get what they need and never click through to anyone.

Philip Kingsley felt this more than most. Its authority comes from decades of trichology expertise which is exactly the kind of informational content AI Overviews absorb. The clicks were being absorbed and Philip Kingsley was rarely the brand the AI actually named. Across the category it held just 5% share of voice. For a brand with that much genuine expertise, it was competing far below its weight.

‍

The engagement icon

The engagement

AI systems lean heavily on real conversations when they build answers and Reddit is one of the places they trust most. If Philip Kingsley wanted to be named in those answers it needed to be part of those conversations in a credible way.

We built a proprietary Reddit strategy around two kinds of community. In branded spaces the aim was to give people who already knew Philip Kingsley a place to discuss it. In non-branded hair care communities, the aim was to make sure the brand came up naturally in the discussions people were already having about hair and scalp health.

The centrepiece was an AMA. One of Philip Kingsley’s own trichologists hosted an Ask Me Anything in r/Haircare, an established community with over 500,000 weekly visitors. This mattered for two reasons. Reddit users are quick to spot and punish anything that feels like marketing so putting a real expert in front of them openly was the right way to earn attention. And an expert answering real questions in a well-trafficked community creates exactly the kind of content AI systems treat as a trusted source.

‍

The results icon

The results

AI referral traffic rose by 586%. People were now arriving at Philip Kingsley from AI tools, which means the brand was being named and cited in the answers rather than bypassed by them.

The quality of that traffic was just as striking. Visitors arriving from AI referrals converted at 1.5 times the rate of the brand’s other marketing channels. That makes sense when you think about it. By the time someone clicks through from an AI answer they’ve already been told this is the expert brand for their problem so they arrive further along in their decision.

Overall, if AI Overviews are eating your informational traffic, writing more content for your own site won’t fix it on its own. You have to show up where the AI does its reading. For Philip Kingsley that meant Reddit, and it meant leading with the brand’s real expertise rather than its marketing. The bigger lesson is that AI traffic shouldn’t be thought of as a consolation prize for lost clicks. It arrives smaller, but it arrives more convinced.

‍

From the client
graphic quotation marksgraphic quotation marks
Looking for more?
Get in touch

Our team of experts are standing by to discuss how we can help to optimise and transform your business through digital-first marketing.

Privacy Policy Cookie Policy